Why do people sometimes behave very differently at work, even when they have similar

skills, experience or responsibilities?

And why can the same person behave differently from one situation to another?

Workplace behaviour is rarely driven by one thing.

It emerges from an interaction between the person, what they are trying to achieve, how they are feeling, the people around them and the environment in which they are working.

That is important because behaviour is what other people actually experience.

It shows up in how we make decisions, communicate, respond to pressure, collaborate, manage disagreement, take responsibility and adapt when circumstances change.

Understanding workplace behaviour therefore requires us to look beyond personality alone.

Behaviour Is Not the Same as Personality

Personality describes relatively enduring patterns and tendencies. Behaviour is what somebody actually does in a particular situation.

The two are related, but they are not interchangeable.

Research into personality at work increasingly recognises that behavioural expression depends partly on the situation. Different workplace cues, demands and expectations can make particular tendencies more or less likely to appear.

A person who is naturally sociable, for example, may still become quiet in an unfamiliar senior meeting. Someone who usually appears calm may become much more directive when the consequences of a decision increase. A highly collaborative person may behave differently when time is limited and they believe rapid action is required.

The person has not necessarily changed. The situation has.

This is why workplace behaviour is better understood as the result of an interaction between personal tendencies and environmental conditions rather than as a fixed expression of personality.

Why the Same Person Can Behave Differently at Work

People are not behaviourally identical from morning to evening or from one situation to another.

  • Workload changes.
  • Relationships change.
  • Priorities conflict.
  • Consequences increase.
  • People become tired, frustrated, confident, uncertain, motivated or disengaged.
  • Their role may be clear in one situation and ambiguous in another.

Research into behaviour and performance at work increasingly recognises this within-person variability rather than assuming that somebody behaves consistently in every circumstance.

That creates an important question for leaders:

What is happening around this person that may be influencing the behaviour we are seeing?

It does not remove personal accountability. It gives us more information with which to understand the behaviour and decide what to do next.

What Influences Behaviour in the Workplace?

There is no single list that explains every behaviour. Several factors commonly interact.

1) Personal Tendencies and Experience

People bring individual differences to work. These can include personality, previous experience, learned habits, values, confidence, capability and preferred ways of working.

Those tendencies can influence how somebody initially approaches a situation. But they do not determine every response.

Experience can also change what a person does. A new manager may avoid a difficult performance conversation because they lack confidence.

After practising, receiving feedback and seeing what works, their behaviour may become more direct and constructive. This is one reason we should be cautious about describing behaviour as fixed.

2) Emotional Awareness and Regulation

Emotions influence attention, judgement, communication and interpersonal behaviour at work. The issue is not whether people experience emotion. They will.The stronger question is what happens next. Can the person recognise what they are experiencing? Can they regulate their response sufficiently to choose behaviour that remains appropriate to the situation?

A leader may feel frustrated without becoming aggressive. They may feel anxious without avoiding a necessary decision. They may recognise somebody else’s concern without immediately becoming defensive.

Emotional intelligence therefore contributes to workplace behaviour partly through our ability to notice, interpret and regulate emotional information.

3) Resilience and Pressure

Pressure can change behaviour. Someone who collaborates easily in normal conditions may become controlling when deadlines tighten.

Another person may become less assertive. Someone else may continue pushing despite evidence that an approach needs to change.

This is why understanding behaviour under pressure can be particularly valuable. Resilience is not simply the ability to endure difficult circumstances.

It involves behavioural capabilities that help people respond, recover, adapt and continue functioning effectively when demands increase.

The question is not simply: Is this person resilient?

It is: What happens to their behaviour when the conditions become more difficult?

4) Motivation

Motivation helps explain why people direct effort towards particular goals, how much effort they apply and how long they persist.

People can also be motivated by different things. Autonomy may matter strongly to one employee. Recognition may matter more to another.

Someone may be particularly motivated by growth, purpose, reward, collaboration or well-being. Those differences can influence behaviour.

A person who feels ownership of a task may approach it very differently from somebody who believes every decision is being controlled. An employee who can see the purpose behind difficult work may persist where another person disengages.

Motivation does not explain every behaviour, but it helps us understand why people choose, sustain or withdraw effort.

5) Other People Influence Behaviour

Behaviour does not occur in isolation. Leaders, colleagues, customers and teams all create social cues. People notice what gets rewarded.

They notice what gets ignored. They notice whether disagreement is safe. They notice whether leaders do what they say. They notice how colleagues behave when something goes wrong.

Over time, those signals can shape what people believe is expected, acceptable or worthwhile.

This is one reason leadership behaviour matters so much. Leaders are not simply managing the behaviour of other people. Their own behaviour becomes part of the environment to which other people are responding.

6) Systems and the Working Environment Matter Too

Sometimes we try to solve a behavioural problem by focusing only on the individual. But the environment may also be contributing.

At flowprofiler®, one way we examine this is through the Enabling Four:

Rules: Are expectations, policies and processes sufficiently clear?

Roles: Do people understand where their role begins and ends?

Responsibilities: Is accountability clear?

Resources: Do people have the time, information, authority, capability and support required to do what is expected?

An organisation can ask people to behave differently while maintaining systems that make the desired behaviour difficult. For example, leaders may be told to delegate while still being held personally accountable for every operational decision.

Teams may be encouraged to collaborate while performance measures reward individual competition. Employees may be asked to take ownership while lacking the authority or information required to do so.

When behaviour is not changing, it is therefore useful to examine both the person and the environment.

Aptitude, Attitude and Approach

Another useful distinction is our Triple A Framework:

Aptitude: Can the person do the job?

Attitude: What is the person’s mindset and willingness towards what is required?

Approach: How are they actually behaving?

These three questions help avoid a common management mistake.

A behavioural problem is not always a capability problem. And a capability problem is not always a motivation problem.

Someone may know exactly what to do but not be doing it consistently. Another person may be willing but lack the required skill. Someone else may have both capability and willingness but be working within systems that make effective behaviour difficult. Good diagnosis comes before intervention.

What Is Behavioural Intelligence?

Behavioural intelligence is the ability to develop greater insight into workplace behaviour and use that understanding to make more deliberate choices.

It involves recognising patterns in ourselves and others while remaining aware that context matters. For a leader, that might mean noticing:

  • I become much more controlling when pressure increases.
  • I avoid difficult conversations when I am uncertain about the relationship.
  • This person appears disengaged, but perhaps I have not understood what motivates them.
  • The team is not taking ownership, but have we genuinely given them the authority to do so?

Insight is useful when it leads to better questions and better choices. It becomes less useful when we turn behavioural information into labels.

What Behavioural Assessment Can Tell Us

Behavioural assessment can provide another source of information about patterns in how somebody reports behaving at work. Used well, it can help people recognise tendencies they may not otherwise have considered.

  • It can help a leader identify questions such as:
  • Where might my behaviour be helping?
  • Where might I be overusing a strength?
  • What changes when pressure increases?
  • Which behaviours may need more deliberate attention?
  • What motivates me?
  • How might somebody else experience my approach?

Assessment can therefore improve the quality of reflection, coaching and development conversations.

What Behavioural Assessment Cannot Tell Us

  • An assessment cannot tell us with certainty exactly what somebody will do tomorrow.
  • It cannot fully explain why a particular behaviour occurred.
  • It cannot remove the influence of context.
  • And it should not become a substitute for observation, conversation or professional judgement.
  • Behaviour is too dynamic for that.

Assessment should only give us more useful questions to ask, rather than encourage us to believe that we already have all the answers.

The flowprofiler® Perspective

flowprofiler® is its own body of novel, validated research into workplace behaviour.

The flowprofiler® assessment family explores workplace behaviour across emotional intelligence, resilience and motivation.

The complete flowprofiler® assessment brings together 18 dimensions.

Importantly, behaviour is considered across two states: Day to Day and Under Pressure

This two-state perspective recognises something that matters greatly at work:

  • The behaviour somebody demonstrates when conditions are manageable may not be identical to the behaviour they demonstrate when demands increase.
  • A leader may usually collaborate effectively but become overly independent under pressure.
  • Someone who is normally adaptable may begin holding tightly to familiar approaches.
  • A person who communicates confidently day to day may become less assertive when consequences rise.

The idea is not to label behaviour as good or bad. It is to understand whether the behaviour is helping the person respond effectively to what the situation requires.

That is why flowprofiler® uses behavioural ranges rather than simply treating more as better.

  • A capability can be underused.
  • It can provide a solid base.
  • It can operate effectively in flow.
  • And it can be overused.
  • The question is always:

Is this behaviour helping in this situation?

Behaviour Change Starts With Better Understanding

Workplace behaviour is complex because people are complex.

  • Personality matters.
  • Experience matters.
  • Emotion matters.
  • Resilience matters.
  • Motivation matters.
  • Leadership matters.
  • Roles, expectations, systems and resources matter.
  • And the interaction between all of them matters.

That means there is rarely one simple explanation for behaviour. But there is a practical place to begin.

  1. Observe what is happening.
  2. Understand the situation.
  3. Ask what capability is required.
  4. Consider what may be motivating or constraining the person.
  5. Look at what changes under pressure.
  6. Then decide whether the issue is one of aptitude, attitude, approach or environment.

Because understanding behaviour should not be about attaching a label. It should help people make better choices about what they do next.

Explore Workplace Behaviour

References

Barsade, S. G., & Gibson, D. E. (2007). Why does affect matter in organizations? Academy of Management Perspectives, 21(1), 36–59. https://doi.org/10.5465/AMP.2007.24286163

Deci, E. L., Olafsen, A. H., & Ryan, R. M. (2017). Self-determination theory in work organizations: The state of a science. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 4, 19–43. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-orgpsych-032516-113108

Kanfer, R., & Chen, G. (2016). Motivation in organizational behavior: History, advances and prospects. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 136, 6–19. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.obhdp.2016.06.002

Tett, R. P., Toich, M. J., & Ozkum, S. B. (2021). Trait activation theory: A review of the literature and applications to five lines of personality dynamics research. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 8, 199–233. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-orgpsych-012420-062228

van Vianen, A. E. M. (2018). Person–environment fit: A review of its basic tenets. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 5, 75–101. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-orgpsych-032117-104702